Johnson trailed his opponent by about 200 votes statewide. Three days after the election, officials in Jim Wells County, a remote place in the southern part of the state, suddenly “found” something labeled Box 13, containing hundreds of ballots filled out by people who miraculously had voted in alphabetical order and with the same handwriting. Once these were counted, Johnson won by 87 votes.
That was in the days of strong political bosses, long before smartphones and the pressures social media can sometimes exert for embarrassment and justice. And there was no president in Washington asserting election fraud despite never offering tangible proof.
Utah may be dominated by one party, but the case for widespread fraud here is hard to take seriously. Still, there are problems.
In Utah, the Office of the Legislative Auditor General in 2024 found that voter rolls contained about 1,400 names of deceased voters that should have been removed. About half of those had been sent mail-in ballots. Two ballots had been filled out and cast.
Also, auditors found 300 cases in which voters had been given two voter I.D. numbers plus almost 450 records involving two voters claiming the same driver license number. Some people had apparently voted twice in the same election.
State records currently list 2,072,506 registered voters in Utah. If you add up all the names of dead voters, duplicate I.D. numbers and duplicate licenses, it makes up 0.001% of registered voters.
In an era of charged feelings toward election irregularities, that may be enough to force change. Some members of the House Public Utilities and Energy Committee clearly agonized this week during a hearing on HB479, a bill that would change Utah’s near universal vote-by-mail system.
Rep. Nicholeen Peck, R-Tooele County, said that after countless emails and texts from constituents on both sides, she had finally decided to “err on … the side of the (idea that) people need to feel secure. They need to know that we care about the strength of those elections.” She voted to recommend the bill to the floor of the House.
House Majority Leader Casey Snider, who also sits on the committee, said it’s clear some people voted in recent elections who shouldn’t legally have been able to do so. He doesn’t believe any of that changed any election outcomes, “but I don’t believe that everybody feels that way.” Voting for the bill, he argued, would restore electoral confidence.
The bill passed out of committee, 8-3. If it becomes law, by 2029 Utah voters would have to opt in, either to an option that allows them to mail ballots in, or to one that allows them to physically hand a paper ballot and a valid I.D. to poll workers standing guard over a drop box, but only during certain hours in the last few days of an election. Everyone else would have to vote in person at a polling location.
The bill’s sponsor, Rep. Jefferson S. Burton, R-Salem, said he believes the bill would result in far fewer people voting by mail.
It’s worth pausing here to reflect on 20 years ago, a time dominated by different passions. As I wrote back then, people in Utah and several other states were reacting strongly to new electronic voting machines put in place thanks in part to federal funding after the 2000 presidential election punch-card debacle.
People were up in arms over those new machines, debating, as I wrote, “over accuracy, computer programs, independent verification and the ability to tamper with the system.”
Allegations against the machines grew to the point where the clerk-auditor in Emery County decided to get an independent group to examine the machines. But once the machines were open, the warranty was voided and the state no longer could guarantee the machines hadn’t been compromised.
The point here is that, while a state should do all it can to eliminate irregularities, no voting system is completely above suspicion.
Power is a strong motivator. Today, as in 1948, it always pays to watch politicians closely where elections are concerned.
The Constitution gives election authority to the states, which is also the entity most capable of shoring up trust in that process. The day may come when emotions settle and tension ease in Utah. For now, however, it appears voting may be about to get a bit more complicated.
RSS Feed